
Every great performer must take a final bow. Please join us as we bid a fond farewell to some well known conflicts that have provided outstanding support to contemporary romance.
At a black tie reception, co-hosted by the talented authors whose books would not have been possible without them, we will usher into retirement the following methods of keeping our modern couples hundreds of pages away from their HEA:
1. I was hurt once, and will never allow anyone to get close enough to hurt me again.*
(*Vigorous snogging excluded)
2. I am a brutal warrior, too dangerous for your alluring softness.
3. I do love you, but … the person you think I am? In point of fact, I am someone else entirely.
4. I can’t have a relationship right now. I have to work. Really hard.
5. You are so incredibly hot, but there’s an excellent chance you are also a murderer.
6. I am not worthy, because I am poor or because you are wealthy or both. Anyway, tracks are involved.
7. You cheated on me (at least that’s how it looked from behind a tree. 700 feet away. In the rain. Not that I’m telling you about it.).
8. You’re a drop dead gorgeous bachelor stud, and I — while my nipples pebble with the best of them (honestly, they could cut glass) — am not.
9. We’re really good friends. That’s no way to build a relationship!!
10. We can’t be together because… I’m not sure, actually. I am dumb as a rock.
We are also delighted to announce that we will have Parlé-Quinn Publishers on hand to introduce their new line of 21st century conflicts (for flexible OLED e-readers of course):
1. I want to have a baby the natural way, but he insists on IVF and pre-implantation screening.
2. Our courtship has been conducted on Twitter. What if he expects me to use more than 140 characters at a time in conversation?
3. I’d like to make her my wife, but she says she’ll quit her job to raise babies if I do.
4. How can I tell her I’m the geek from high school with a face transplant?
5. The ultimate secret baby: her eggs, his sperm, a gestational surrogate, and two adoptive parents. Who will pay for college?
6. She’s a traditional girl who believes strongly in the old-fashioned threesome. Is there room in her heart for … just one more?
7. Can their happiness survive his knowledge of his true origins: her cloning lab and a skin cell lifted from a really hot model?
8. Can he accept her for who she truly is underneath the neuroenhancers? (Somewhat dim, chronically sleepy, and much less likely to keep her music or closet so well organized)
9. In an envelope-pushing bid to overcome speciesism in the romance genre once and for all…

Strangers. Stranded on a desert island. Will love blossom?
Disclaimer: This is just a little fantasy of mine. In all seriousness, regular readers know that contemporary is my favorite subgenre of romance, and I have loved books with all of the “retiring” conflicts listed above. But I now really appreciate the fresh yet believable conflict, especially those rooted in well-developed characters. What do you think?
Related posts:
- Look! My New Kindle 2.0! Out of the box and reading my first book in under ten minutes. YES!! Here are some blurry (sorry, I...
- Stock siblings in romance Have you ever noticed that in romance series featuring male siblings, you can often find the same character types? This...
- Manhood Mania: Help Me and Enter to Win! Note: To post or read comments, you have to click the post title. Sorry! I am working on a post...
- I’m over at Dear Author Today Head over to Dear Author to read my Letter of Opinion, Romance and the Boundaries of the Self, in which...
- Sometimes My Worlds Collide This is NSFW…unless you teach Women’s Studies, in which case it IS work. I just picked up today’s office mail…...
- Romance Novels as an “Addiction” I was looking for reviews of Mary Jo Putney’s The Rake, when I found a 2004 AAR Interview with her...





#1 by Kat on May 28, 2009 - 9:19 pm
Hilarious! And if I come across a book with camel changelings, I’ll know just whom to blame.
#2 by Sherry Thomas on May 28, 2009 - 9:39 pm
ROTFL, especially at …Just one more?
Total cavity utilization.
#3 by Ann Somerville on May 28, 2009 - 9:57 pm
Please don’t give the lousy authors of the world more ideas, Jessica? We’re on a hiding to nothing as it is!
#4 by Nicola O. on May 28, 2009 - 11:32 pm
Auuggh! Jessica, what do you have against romance? What’s left if you retire those plotlines?
I do want to mention that I’m pretty sure I saw your New #5 on All My Children in the early 90′s.
#5 by dharmagirl on May 28, 2009 - 11:49 pm
this is too funny, jessica. love it.
(but, um, my sorry draft novels include more than one of your retirees…hmmmm. but, you’ve thoughtfully included some inspiration for new directions. hee!)
#6 by Ann Somerville on May 28, 2009 - 11:54 pm
Ooh, can I suggest a no.11 for the Parle-Quinn line?

“How would he ever be able to tell his lover he was pregnant?”
[There just isn't enough mpreg in romance, if you ask me.]
#7 by Nicola O. on May 29, 2009 - 1:44 am
@ Ann Somerville:
corollary: “and would she believe the baby was hers after he’d lied to her about that other thing?”
#8 by Jessica on May 29, 2009 - 5:25 am
Nicola O. wrote:
I know, While there are some plotlines that I really personally think are way overdone, even the oldest conflict can be made fresh in the right hands (so take heart dharmagirl!)
And I don’t know about All My Children, but #5 really happened, in California, in the 1990s (http://www.surrogacy.com/legals/jaycee/jayceesum.html)
#9 by Victoria Janssen on May 29, 2009 - 7:41 am
LOL!
#10 by carolyn crane (CJ) on May 29, 2009 - 8:11 am
Hilarious! I really want to read the face transplant geek from high school! It has lots of potential for drama and backstory. But your retirees are even funnier. You’re right, if they all retired, we’d have nothing to read! What’s even sadder, is that I have read book with multiple of your retirees in the same plot..and loved it.
Uh, Nicola, was that Erica Kane? That weird doctor harvested her eggs, or was it when she went in for an abortion, and instead he made the baby grow to full term???
#11 by Lynne Connolly on May 29, 2009 - 8:28 am
I heart you Jessica. You made my Friday.
#12 by jillsorenson on May 29, 2009 - 10:20 am
I’m proud to say I’ve done some of these. Please don’t let them all retire! : )
#13 by Lusty Reader on May 29, 2009 - 10:57 am
I’d be sad if ALL those were retired, but your new ones are hilarious and very au courant maybe even avant-garde. Ok no more franglais.
Can you also retire: I can’t be with you because I’m a vampire and will live forever and you are not and will die.
#14 by Jessica on May 29, 2009 - 11:27 am
jillsorenson wrote:
Jill, I know. I have read Crash Into Me, remember? And I convict you on counts 1, 3, 4, and 5 for that book alone! But it can be done badly, or well, as you know. I was reading the excerpt of CIM in the checkout line yesterday in Glamour(?).
Nice pic!
#15 by BevBB on May 29, 2009 - 12:09 pm
So, how would you feel about a mongoose-shifter heroine? And considering what the rest of her family turned into she was actually kind of lucky.
#16 by ReacherFan on May 29, 2009 - 12:12 pm
Dear Jessica,
I an a human female in a manage relationship with with vampire and werewolf, but deeply attracted to our cyborg neighbor, Blade, who mows the grass with no clothes on. I know he’s a man machine, but I think I can teach to love and put down the toilet seat. Is there a chance for us as a foursome? Can Vlad accept his attraction to Blade? Will Rolf run away in wolf form with the collie from work? Any advice would be appreciated.
Signed
Progressive in Seattle Suburbs
#17 by Jennifer B on May 29, 2009 - 12:27 pm
Picking myself up off the floor. Thank you for that, LOL.
#18 by Shannon C. on May 29, 2009 - 2:15 pm
I love when you make posts like this. I laughed. Hard. Especially at 2 on your new ideas, mostly because I can forsee actual for serious blog posts about that very issue.
#19 by Maya M. on May 29, 2009 - 9:45 pm
Hee.
By any chance are you a Jasper Fforde fan? Because one of the bits that made me laugh most in ‘The Big Over Easy’ was an epigraph written in newspaper article style about a retirement banquet held for the Murder in a Locked Room mystery motif, which had to be cancelled, due to the murder of the guest of honor – in a locked room.
#20 by willaful on May 30, 2009 - 2:17 pm
Awesome! I am especially thrilled to see the back of no. 9, even if only in fantasy.
And am also dying to read the story of the face transplant geek. Brings to mind Jonathon Coulton’s “The Future Soon,” my husband’s favorite song:
“I won’t always be this way/when the things that make me weak and strange get engineered away.”
#21 by Tumperkin on May 30, 2009 - 3:30 pm
Commentwhore here to say – VERY funny Jessica!
#22 by Holly on May 30, 2009 - 3:46 pm
I am so very sad that I didn’t come up with number 9 myself. That could have been my breakthrough idea to take me from reader to romance author! Camel shifters, how thou devastate me!
Also, this is just wrong…
ReacherFan wrote:
Everyone knows Blade and Vlad are secretly having an affair and Rolf is jealous over it. And the collie from work is really Rolf’s long lost child from a previous relationship, so Progressive is wrong to be worried he’ll run away with her.
#23 by ReacherFan on May 30, 2009 - 11:08 pm
Holly wrote:
Those lying male sluts. I get even with them and have the Demon Lord’s baby!